Wow that's a lot of death. Let's see if we can parse this...
I think Znirk is right -- likely all the kill powers went off without overlap (PGO, SK, Vig, NK).
mpolo's thought that moody's PGO killed generalz doesn't make sense to me. I'm thinking it's more likely jimbob targeted generalz. He already said in his last post on D2 that his top picks for scum were GoP (lynched), generalz, and Madge -- it would make sense for him to target one of the two remaining unlynched in his top scum picks, and since Madge is alive...
moody killing generalz doesn't make sense for another roundabout reason anyway -- his death. He knew he was hunkering down last night as a PGO, so why would he accept any notes? The PGO note states that it would target "the first person to attempt
to interact with him." There was no reason to accept a note from any town power because that person would be dead just by the attempt, and obviously he wouldn't want to accept one from non-town, so he could have safely denied notes. Which means that if he'd been targeted by generalz, he should still be alive, right?
Although that power says the "first person..." Presumably all kills happen simultaneously last, which means if someone (say Sabrar) targeted moody to Watch, he would come closer to first in the order than generalz. It could be conceivable that Sabrar targeted moody, dying to moody's PGO, leaving moody open to attack from anyone after. Still can't see moody accepting notes last night, though. Sabrar's power didn't come with note-sending afaik, so if generalz targeted moody, it would be the only note he received, and as discussed earlier, there would be no reason to accept any notes.
Generalz had to get people to accept his notes to kill them. He apparently didn't send one to Madge as he said he was going to. If he was expecting to be alive at start of day today, that's a surprising decision for him to make. Would make town (more) distrustful of him as it would be going back on his promise that he would, and there was no guarantee Madge would be targeted by another note-sending power that he could conceivably claim was his. Unless he did try to send Madge a note and was redirected. Hmm... possibility: scum!Madge would probably have more than an inkling that generalz was the SK. Scum!Madge gets presumed SK to target her at night and has scum!redirector (possibly herself) send him to someone else that is a threat to Mafia, thus scoring a double Mafia-directed NK. I could see her redirecting him to jimbob (given the mention above that she was among his three scummiest at last post). Would jimbob have accepted a note, if he thought generalz was sending one to Madge and therefore he would be protected against the possible SK?
I could see Sabrar targeting moody for Watch -- moody was pretty much confirmed town, so it was possible someone would target him for the kill. moody didn't tell anyone (aside from mpolo?) about or imply his PGO status that I can tell (which is in and of itself curious -- somewhat understandable, but in a game like this with so many powers, you gotta think that some Town power is likely to hit you first and make you vulnerable again before the kills process), so Sabrar wouldn't have known not to target him.
So, my guesses are:
jimbob Vig'd generalz
generalz SK'd jimbob (by way of scum!redirect from scum!Madge?)
moody PGO'd Sabrar
remaining Mafia NK'd moody (only possible bc he PGO'd Sabrar who targeted him "earlier" in the night)
Man that would be damn elegant (and lucky for Mafia) if it is correct. No way for generalz to defend his towniness or get scum into trouble by saying he did in fact target Madge.
The only other option I can see if scum had redirect and redirected generalz would be that Mafia targeted jimbob for NK and redirected generalz to moody. They definitely wouldn't have tried to double up kills on moody as they wouldn't have known he had a defense (offensive defense) mechanism of any kind. Also that double-up would leave one of our four dead folks from last night (likely jimbob or moody) still alive, so it's a non-starter.MMMII mods:
Am I reading the PGO note correctly there? Kills the first person in night action order to target PGO, then leaves him open to other targeting abilities? If the PGO kills someone who was targeting him with a kill, does that kill still succeed, or is it blocked?
With a semi-nightless night and notes that have to be accepted, how do any redirecting abilities work? If A sends night action with note to B, but C redirects A to D, when is the note sent? Could B accept the note and then just not see anything come of it because of the redirect? Or are all notes held until a certain point?
If Z sends night action with note to Y, but Y wants to redirect Z to X, could Y wait until they see a note in their inbox before submitting their redirect?
I'm guessing at this point that you won't need any replacements, but just in case, I'm asking questions as if I were a player, so I don't want any more info than you would give them