BoomFrog wrote:And we have accidentally stumbled on the piece of your logic that I had not understood. Madge flip had nothing to do with my alignment, just with how many scum are left. It was painful but at least I got my question answered.
Are you serious? Do you expect me to believe it took you
, with all your brilliance and cleverness and wit, four days
of discussion to get my snarky remark
BoomFrog wrote: Hari is a cold and calculating person. And he's read enough games to know defending teammates is the most common way for scum to get caught, and he's inexperienced enough to just try and be pure town and lynch his teammate accidentally D1.
Hari’s not a newbie. I asked him when I welcomed him in the Halloween game. Greeting and asking new people if they have any mafia experience is one of the items on the bessie checklist, along with analyzing confirmation posts, setup spec, and tunneling (hmm).
cemper93 wrote:Hmm. In the scenario where BoomFrog had already made a decision to woof before the game started, wouldn't he have done it anyway, no matter who his partners are? I don't see him as the kind of player who would not do something just on the off chance that a newbie might react weirdly.
Sabrar asked me to read BoomFrog with the assumption that he’s town. I spent a lot of time thinking about the whole woof gambit, and because of the flips I could see a case for town!BoomFrog. (reminder,my theory is that scum!BoomFrog did not immediately join scum chat so that reactions would be natural.) I have trouble seeing scum!BoomFrog trying this with Peaceful Whale unless he knew there was someone that could (1) play along in thread, and (2) manage Peaceful Whale, so to speak, and I think the most likely candidates were me and moody (ha ha, Madge would have been soooo all over this!), and not flicky (because newbie). But in trying to explain my point to you, I can now see a case for proceeding with the plan regardless, even with two newbies, because Peaceful Whale did stumble early in the game (see Sleepgate and the rest of my D1 content).
cemper93 wrote:Yes, word! I have put in a request with wam to be replaced. I am not able to provide very meaningful content in this game anymore; I simply lack the time for not only reading the high-volume posts, but thinking them through as well. Sorry everyone!
Goshfrickindarnit. I have said this someplace buried in the previous 29 pages, but we’re going to scare any potential newbies away; cemper is not a newbie, he is an experienced player, and he can’t keep up with the content overload. flicky is having trouble keeping up too, and reminder flicky signed up for the game because it is a newbie game. If I have a spare five hours
, I will reread the game again sorted by author, which I haven’t dome for a while, to see if any of this content is just empty posting to appear townie. I will also try to look for people that keep repeating the same content over and over again, and are prodding others with requests to continually repeat themselves as a distraction.
LaserGuy wrote:I feel like the reactions from other players to his persistent tunneling on me, particularly the "slip" business, points to him being Town. Scum tunnels have a built-in receptive audience in the form of buddies that are likely to at least respond to or comment on their buddy's points and try to advance their case. The fact that Hari has been pushing this case since D1 and has received so little interest to me points to a Town tunnel (more specifically, it points to TvT). I think if Hari was scum with a buddy in the game, he would have got more traction at this point, or would have dropped it by now and advanced a different argument or a moved to a different target.
Interesting, Hari gets town cred for tunneling, I get scum cred.
bessie seems really frustrated this game. Sorry if it's at all to do with the way I'm playing.
Ah, my young bird, this is nothing. If you haven't seen me really pissed off you need to sign up for more games.
jimbobmacdoodle wrote:You might as well claim properly, LaserGuy. Hari Seldon has already said he'll likely vote you, which will be L-2, and I expect BoomFrog will switch back if there isn't a swing to Hari. But do as you wish.
This is a very odd comment. You should know that there is not a lynch that is a done deal until the mod calls deadline, look at D1 in this game (more examples available upon request, like D1 of WoT2, D4 of Crossover, etc). Why the quick push on LaserGuy to claim? And why the certainty about his lynch?
MasterOfAll, thank you very much for replacing.
MasterOfAll wrote:So, following that logic, without bothering to consider players' actual posts, leads me to think that bessie is scum with either jimbobmacdoodle or LaserGuy as her scum-bro.
The Peaceful Whale wagon has been the subject of much debate on D2. That wagon gained traction very late, and some players (me, Madge, Vicarin) were already gone for the day by then. I’ll let you read through the posts first and draw your own conclusion, but I don’t expect you to fully analyze 29 pages of content feel free to ask me any questions.