xkcd

plytho

Madge is looking pretty scummy today. I think I'd be happy with her lynch, except there's one specific thing that she commented on D2 that pretty strongly pointed to her being non-scum. SK is possible, I guess, though her complaining about being roleblocked feels genuine to me. Can you point out th...

plytho

In the interest of reading into players' content, could anyone who has a posting restriction and not yet claimed it just post explicitly what it is? I have none. I think I was clear with mine, but I'll spell it out. I have to have a vote on me at all times except in the last 24 hours, even if it's ...

plytho

And I count four superhero threads on the first page. Those aren't quite bulk numbers. Or do you want to talk about a bunch of new movies without starting a thread for each?

plytho

I have no posting restriction.

plytho

Is there a possibility that Madge, Bard and LaserGuy are all scum? Is it possible they're all scum? Absolutely, I would not be surprised to find that Bard and LaserGuy are on one scum team and Madge is on the other. Is it possible they're all scum on the same team? Highly unlikely in my opinion, as...

plytho

Bard’s a much more active player than the previous three I read and I have a lot less time today to read. Here are his posts referring to the LaserGuy claim before the full claim. Confirmation post with first breadcrumb of LaserGuy love Second breadcrumb post Claim LaserGuy is town Been crumbing all...

plytho

As for researcher, that is one of our top picks when playing vanilla Pandemic, it's an incredibly useful character for us. On the other hand, we hardly use the soldier at all in Legacy. We're researcher fans as well. That and dispatcher. They're usually essential for our curing strategy. Medic is n...

plytho

It just doesn't feel right to say "he shouldn't ever be a play" since I have pretty much no idea what the set up looks like or what could possibly happen going into the future. If you're truly his lover then from your pov he should never ever be the play regardless of circumstances. Does ...

plytho

SDK wrote:Okay, it got harder. Lost our first game in May and had our first death. Those who have played probably remember why... God damn.

This sort of thing is why I enjoyed that game so much. I don't remember what happened in May though.

plytho

Actually, Bard did call LaserGuy town in that post. Can only make quick hits today, so I'll respond to Jim in a bit. But more importantly, and for reasons I can't really explain, Laserguy should not be a play today. I have verrrrrry good reasons for saying this. I know I'm pulling an SDK here somew...

plytho

Shakespeare III I so want to know what Sabrar posted above! I think my team is doing pretty well. SDK was after me yesterday but I seem to have convinced him I'm not the guild he's looking for. (has there been a star wars theme? I look forward to playing I game with flavor I'm famili...

plytho

Dimochka has 18 posts, even less than Madge, they're of better quality than Madge's though He starts with a+ roleplaying. But he does seem to arrive late every day. His first proper D1 post looks solid. I like how he called SDK being a lyncher possible. Has a decent reads list and town to scum . His...

plytho

Whatever, butting in. Not going to do Madge's whole work for her but I was right about BoomFrog and I think I'm right here as well. and ‘agrees’ with nobody that 2-2 scum is likely. That nobody is bessie who speculated about 2-2 here . Thanks, you're right. I think I remembered someone pointing thi...

plytho

She does seem to be gunning for yolo in these posts Based on very little. Which doesn’t really make all that much sense for a buddy at that point I think. Votes SirG Claims to have targeted SDK with her night action. She switches to yolo right after that previous post. Decent case there, plytho. Yo...

plytho

Next up: kalira, has 15 posts so far, less than Madge but also has one less Day of play so kalira is actually more active than Madge. Starts the game with two big posts analysing D1. I’m pretty sure she covers everyone in those posts. They’re solid analysis and she gets a scumread on YOLO as a resul...

plytho

Here's my read on Madge and why I think she's guild scum. She's lurky: very low post count: 19 posts out of 690. There's no scumhunting except for one short bit, randomly on dimochka. D1: First big post . I agree that Dethstalker looks like a possible timewaster. Might be as good a place to put a ly...

plytho

Right now was what I meant, thanks. Why Madge? She's been on the scummy end of my reads for most of the game which means I found some things scummy and she hasn't posted anything redeeming. She's generally been lurky. I think she might be the quiet third guild member or, if LaserBard is town, one o...

plytho

Sabrar wrote:@plytho: if you had a Vig-shot who would you kill tonight?

Do you mean right now, gun to my head or do I get to make my reads first?

Right now I'd probably target Madge or Bard.

plytho

^ Aside: figured out why some links were broken. If you sort by author then position of posts will change overtime and software won't find it. If you sort by date then this won't occur. That's a nuisance. Thanks for the head's up. I've got a fix for that. If you're searching by author and click a po...

plytho

Assume Bard is scum. He defends LaserGuy at a time when a) the latter is not close to getting lynched - though several people found him scummy and the wagon could have turned against him - and b) there is a good lurker-lynch available in DethStalker. I disagree with this assumption. LaserGuy would ...

plytho

Assume Bard is scum. He defends LaserGuy at a time when a) the latter is not close to getting lynched - though several people found him scummy and the wagon could have turned against him - and b) there is a good lurker-lynch available in DethStalker. I disagree with this assumption. LaserGuy would ...

plytho

(You might have a town tell on Gopher from experience that I don’t have yet.) True enough. With Gopher, I'm so sure he's town based on writing style and a healthy dose of meta. Gopher makes mistakes. He likes to ponder and muse prior to really fully thinking through where those musings lead. He's r...

plytho

Scum will need to hunt scum at some point. Especially the guild team. They've lost 2 members already. In fact, at this stage, it might be more advantageous for scum to hunt other scum, seeing as one team is struggling to survive, and the other might want to reduce the number of NK's to prevent them...

plytho

Well, I'm surprised that Boomfrog is dead, and their role. Less so about bessie. I must have thought something was up with bessie due to her having night chat. It was just mason chat. However, she did say explicitly that she didn't know if SDK was town, which contradicts her role pm. So, if SDK isn...

plytho

Well, I'm surprised that Boomfrog is dead, and their role. Less so about bessie. I must have thought something was up with bessie due to her having night chat. It was just mason chat. However, she did say explicitly that she didn't know if SDK was town, which contradicts her role pm. So, if SDK isn...

plytho

Shakespeare III

Spoiler:

plytho

No time to properly finish this. Overall, plytho's been feeling much more disengaged with the game than I'm used to, especially in Day 2 where I first picked up on it (that was the weird thing I was trying to put words to). There's also the weird way he treated bessie (and me by extension). Either ...

plytho

So yeah, my first point is that Gopher was inconsistent about his question for voting powers. I don’t have a problem with the question in itself (if properly nuanced, like in his most recent statement), I have a problem with the inconsistencies in the defense. And that's fair enough. I personally t...

plytho

Is Gopher the only one that doesn't get what I mean or does nobody else understand why I find him scummy? Please do explain, because I don't get why anyone is on Gopher and I don't remember seeing a proper case (though it's possible it's been made and I forgot). See below. You bring up those two po...

plytho

If that's your only two points against me, I have no idea why you think I'm scum. You think I'm scum because I provided a counterpoint to the dethstalker lynch (You said you like counter-points), and because I generated some claim discussion (however misguided you think I was)? There have been plen...

plytho

If the only reason you're not going to lynch me today is because i'm sick, please don't let that stay your hand. i'd probably be posting more or less the same thing and YOLOSWAG's lackluster claim is the sort of thing i normally base my votes on. not that i'm asking you to vote for me, but i'm kind...

plytho

Talking traffic, everyone can read, spoilered for not mafia related

Spoiler:

plytho

I'm rereading my posts and I'm realising I haven't been pushing Gopher as much as I think I was. I've asked some questions about things he did that seemed fishy but didn't get any response. I know I can come across as a bit scummy, but I refuse to believe that 3 town players would pick me as scum. S...

plytho

I think the main difference is that in AG the sex is the story line, and they're not talking over it with sex-position. Also, it's much less defined by the conventional, heterosexual gaze, and it's better. Yeah, this is what I was thinking, but couldn't find the words for. A lot of the sex in GoT i...

plytho

On the flip side, plytho first interacts with YOLOSWAG in the beginning of Day 2 asking him two questions that went unanswered. plytho did not follow up, and this doesn't seem to have changed plytho's read - plytho calls him town based on Day 1 content (though Day 1 plytho called YOLO "hard to...

plytho

I really like SDK's post. The only thing I disagree with are his reads on me and Gopher

I think I'm going to drop my indie read on him, he's probably town.

plytho

Spoilered for traffic talk. So are you in the traffic biz????????? It's definitely a cool idea. During peak we have a few intersections that are all linked together, so it's the sort of thing you might try with them - but during peak you're probably not all going at full speed anyway and...

plytho

Spoilered for traffic talk. That's clever. Is that compatible with scats? It doesn't seem like it necessarily would be as it would be tricky to make adaptive. But maybe it is? *learns about scats* Yeah, that's one of the challenges. It's pretty straightforward for an isolated interse...

plytho

Her posts to and about DethStalker read very much like a frustrated teammate trying to help a useless, intractable team member. She spends more time talking to and about him than just about anyone else. A quick summary of her interactions with him: - Welcome post , notes his postcount is still 1 an...

plytho

No, I'm trying to figure out why you think this is scummy in the first place. Oh, I didn't get that. Taking the claim at face value, a townie player claims (truthfully) they have a night power that's not a one-shot. This paints a huge target on their head. They're basically telling scum they are a ...

Search found 323 matches